Discourse: Structuralist/Functionalist Principles
Dr. Jacobsen

The structuralist paradigm to discourse analysis defines discourse as "language above the sentence" and is based on the premise that language is a mental phenomenon (thus you'll see shades of Chomsky).  The functionalist paradigm focuses on language use and is based on the premise that language is a social phenomenon.
 
 
 
Structuralist Functionalist
"etic"--analysis based on form "emic"--analysis based on meaning
Code-centered Use-centered
Analyze code first Analyze use first
Referential function Social function
Elements/structures are arbitrary and universal Elements/structures are ethnographically appropriate
All languages equivalent Languages and varieties not necessarily equivalent
One code Code diversity
Fundamental concepts taken for granted Fundamental concepts problematic and to be investigated

Adapted from Deborah Shiffrin, Approaches to Discourse, 1994.